hr payroll

Gusto complaints on Reddit

OpinionDeck found 122 recent Reddit threads mentioning Gusto across 3 subreddits. The most active community is r/smallbusiness, and 6 of these threads are framed as complaints or alternatives.

Data refreshed 2026-05-08

Mention timeline

Monthly thread volume across the 3 subreddits where Gusto is discussed.

2016-08: 1 threads 2017-04: 1 threads 2017-06: 1 threads 2017-10: 1 threads 2018-09: 1 threads 2018-10: 1 threads 2019-01: 1 threads 2019-03: 1 threads 2019-07: 1 threads 2019-10: 1 threads 2020-01: 1 threads 2020-02: 1 threads 2020-04: 3 threads 2020-05: 1 threads 2020-06: 1 threads 2020-08: 1 threads 2020-09: 1 threads 2021-01: 1 threads 2021-02: 1 threads 2021-04: 2 threads 2021-05: 1 threads 2021-11: 1 threads 2021-12: 1 threads 2022-01: 1 threads 2022-02: 3 threads 2022-06: 3 threads 2022-07: 3 threads 2022-09: 1 threads 2022-10: 4 threads 2022-12: 3 threads 2023-01: 2 threads 2023-02: 5 threads 2023-03: 2 threads 2023-04: 1 threads 2023-05: 2 threads 2023-07: 2 threads 2023-08: 1 threads 2023-10: 1 threads 2023-11: 1 threads 2023-12: 2 threads 2024-01: 3 threads 2024-02: 2 threads 2024-03: 2 threads 2024-04: 2 threads 2024-07: 2 threads 2024-08: 1 threads 2024-09: 3 threads 2024-10: 3 threads 2025-01: 3 threads 2025-02: 3 threads 2025-03: 3 threads 2025-04: 4 threads 2025-06: 5 threads 2025-07: 2 threads 2025-08: 3 threads 2025-09: 1 threads 2025-10: 3 threads 2025-11: 4 threads 2025-12: 2 threads 2026-01: 3 threads 2026-02: 4 threads 2026-05: 1 threads 2016-08 2026-05

Where Gusto gets discussed

Top subreddits by share of Gusto-related threads in our sample.

SubredditThreads in sampleShare
r/smallbusiness 92
75%
r/Payroll 25
20%
r/humanresources 5
4%

Top Gusto complaints on Reddit

Threads where users mention switching, alternatives, or frustration with Gusto.

  • Alternatives to Gusto for Payroll r/smallbusiness · u/LakeErie77 · 22 points · Jan 8, 2025

    Hi All, new poster here. I do HR plus other things for my husband's small business of 20 years. We have used Gusto for over ten years. It has been good - until the past couple of months. They moved their customer service overseas. BAD…

  • Gusto vs Justworks for payroll? r/smallbusiness · u/Wrecktangle324 · 2 points · Aug 28, 2020

    Hey everyone, I'm working for small construction company with about 25 employees. We currently use paypro iSolved. It's probably the worst service I have ever used. At this point, we've wasted hundreds of man-hours trying to find…

  • Gusto alternatives for payroll r/smallbusiness · u/OMGkristine · 1 points · Sep 26, 2024

    Long story short, I’m looking for a payroll alternative to Gusto. Have been with them a long time and seen them go progressively downhill. I used to always be able to speak with someone on the phone and now it’s “I have escalated your…

  • Gusto payroll means you are on your own. r/Payroll · u/Funny_Cable7714 · 14 points · Feb 17, 2026

    If you use Gusto, you are on your own. Their support is terrible. You can wait on hold for 30 mins and then they will simply drop the call. If you have a problem you will have to solve it for yourself.

  • Gusto does not informs IRS if you no longer have need for payroll r/Payroll · u/Famous-Pipe-1231 · 5 points · Apr 5, 2024

    So I am in the process of closing my Gusto account and noticed that the IRS requires on Form 941, Line 17, to check a box if that is the final filing. Same principle applies to Form 940 but on the first page for the “Type of Return”. Gusto…

  • is Gusto a good payroll software and has anyone used it before? r/smallbusiness · u/OneAccomplished6369 · 0 points · Feb 26, 2026

    I'm looking to see if its worth switching from Quickbooks.

Other recent Gusto threads

Non-complaint mentions — questions, comparisons, recommendations.

  • This (and future) employee is remote, working from home or office in a state other than the company domicile. I just need something simple that: * is easy to use for the employee * does all the work for me w.r.t. determining and paying…

  • Gusto vs Deel for US payroll, real experiences? r/smallbusiness · 55 points · Nov 10, 2025

    we’re a growing US team with multi state payroll, hourly and salaried, a few off cycle runs, and the usual last minute fixes near close. i’ve used Gusto before for basics and i’m looking at Deel alongside it as we scale. what surprised you…

  • Gusto payroll software - USER BEWARE r/smallbusiness · 31 points · Jul 5, 2022

    Wondering if anyone else has had problems with Gusto not filing state forms as promised? Here is our experience: Gusto claims to file all fed and state payroll forms on your behalf. The fed seems to work ok, but State - not so much. If for…

  • Experience with Gusto for payroll? Guideline for 401k? r/smallbusiness · 28 points · Dec 17, 2021

    I have a small (9-person) advertising agency. We've been through a couple payroll providers and haven't really had a good experience yet. Not having dedicated HR personnel, we need something easy and intuitive. Though I've only needed to…

Stop reading. Start reaching out.

Monitor every new Gusto complaint on Reddit

OpinionDeck watches r/smallbusiness and 2 other subs 24/7. When someone complains about Gusto, you get the lead, the context, and a one-click personalized DM draft. Free during beta.

Monitor Gusto for free

No credit card. Set up in 60 seconds.

Frequently asked

Where do people complain about Gusto on Reddit?
r/smallbusiness, r/Payroll, r/humanresources are the most active subreddits discussing Gusto. The full breakdown of 3 subreddits is below.
How many Gusto mentions are on Reddit?
OpinionDeck found 122 recent threads mentioning Gusto across 3 subreddits, of which 6 are framed as complaints. Data refreshed 2026-05-08.
Can I monitor Gusto mentions on Reddit automatically?
Yes. OpinionDeck monitors Reddit 24/7 for new mentions of any keyword or competitor, alerts you when an unhappy user posts, and helps you draft a personalized reply. Free during beta.

Other hr payroll on Reddit