email marketing

Substack complaints on Reddit

OpinionDeck found 188 recent Reddit threads mentioning Substack across 2 subreddits. The most active community is r/Substack, and 6 of these threads are framed as complaints or alternatives.

Data refreshed 2026-05-23

Mention timeline

Monthly thread volume across the 2 subreddits where Substack is discussed.

2025-02: 1 threads 2025-03: 5 threads 2025-04: 2 threads 2025-05: 12 threads 2025-06: 10 threads 2025-07: 7 threads 2025-08: 6 threads 2025-09: 7 threads 2025-10: 6 threads 2025-11: 2 threads 2025-12: 7 threads 2026-01: 2 threads 2026-02: 6 threads 2026-03: 9 threads 2026-04: 3 threads 2026-05: 103 threads 2025-02 2026-05

Where Substack gets discussed

Top subreddits by share of Substack-related threads in our sample.

SubredditThreads in sampleShare
r/Substack 98
52%
r/Newsletters 90
48%

Top Substack complaints on Reddit

Threads where users mention switching, alternatives, or frustration with Substack.

Other recent Substack threads

Non-complaint mentions — questions, comparisons, recommendations.

  • Substack Is So Inauthentic r/Substack · 93 points · May 21, 2026

    I moved to Substack a few months ago as I do honestly like the simplicity of the web publications (not so much the app versions), particularly for fiction. I haven't even started posting properly yet, but it looks as though gaining…

  • I keep seeing the same questions here: Where do I start? Why isn't mine growing? When should I go paid? So I wrote everything I know into one long guide on my Substack, but here I'm sharing the short version - the stuff that actually moved…

  • My top Substack tip r/Substack · 45 points · May 17, 2026

    I've written this as a reply in so many comments, so I thought I would just make it a post. My top tip for Substack is to write notes, but there's an important caveat. Writing notes using voice dictation is by far the best way to do it. 1.…

  • My grandfather wants his Substack as a book r/Substack · 36 points · May 18, 2026

    My grandfather has been writing on Substack for a couple of years. Last year he mentioned he wanted to turn his posts into an ebook to have the family read. I looked around for something that could do that simply and couldn't find…

Stop reading. Start reaching out.

Monitor every new Substack complaint on Reddit

OpinionDeck watches r/Substack and 1 other subs 24/7. When someone complains about Substack, you get the lead, the context, and a one-click personalized DM draft. Free during beta.

Monitor Substack for free

No credit card. Set up in 60 seconds.

Frequently asked

Where do people complain about Substack on Reddit?
r/Substack, r/Newsletters are the most active subreddits discussing Substack. The full breakdown of 2 subreddits is below.
How many Substack mentions are on Reddit?
OpinionDeck found 188 recent threads mentioning Substack across 2 subreddits, of which 6 are framed as complaints. Data refreshed 2026-05-23.
Can I monitor Substack mentions on Reddit automatically?
Yes. OpinionDeck monitors Reddit 24/7 for new mentions of any keyword or competitor, alerts you when an unhappy user posts, and helps you draft a personalized reply. Free during beta.

Other email marketing on Reddit